The MacBook Deal That Turned Deadly
A recent high-school graduate answered a Craigslist ad for a MacBook Pro and never came home. The case — and the pattern behind it — is the clearest reason to rethink how we sell our used Macs.
Encore Editorial · Sep 10, 2026 · 8 min read

The ad was for a MacBook Pro. That is where this story begins, and it is worth sitting with how ordinary that is — a laptop listed on Craigslist, a fair-looking price, a buyer who wanted one. On the night of May 11, 2011, Garrett Berki, a recent La Jolla High School graduate with his whole adult life in front of him, drove into the Paradise Hills neighborhood of San Diego to buy that computer. It was around ten o'clock. His girlfriend, Ali Faudoa, was in the car with him. By the end of the night he had been shot behind the wheel of that same car, and he did not survive.
More than a decade later, Garrett Berki's name still comes up whenever people in San Diego talk about the danger of meeting a stranger from the internet. We think it is a story worth telling plainly and completely, not for the shock of it, but because the lesson inside it is the single clearest argument for why the way we sell our used electronics needs to change.
An ad with nothing behind it
There was no MacBook Pro. According to the trial coverage, the listing was bait — a lure set by three young men, Rashon Abernathy, then eighteen, along with Seandell Jones and Shaquille Jordan, who had arranged the meeting not to sell a computer but to rob whoever came to buy it. When Garrett and Ali arrived at the agreed spot, there was no negotiation to speak of. As KPBS reported from the courtroom, the group grabbed the couple's cash and their cellphones and piled into a stolen car.
What Garrett did next is painfully human. He didn't drive home and call it a loss. He followed the car — trying, by most accounts, to get a look at the license plate so the robbery could be reported. The chase moved onto State Route 54. The two cars left the freeway and came to rest front-to-front in a cul-de-sac, a dead end with nowhere left for either driver to go. It was there, cornered, that Abernathy fired a single shot through the windshield of Garrett's car. The round struck Garrett in the shoulder. He died roughly forty-five minutes later. He was eighteen years old.
Nothing about the computer caused this. Every dangerous moment in Garrett Berki's last night flowed from one thing: the arrangement to meet a stranger, in a place that stranger chose, to trade cash for a valuable, easily-pocketed device. The MacBook Pro was only the reason the two parties were ever in the same place.
The trial, and why the case stuck
The investigation and trial were covered closely in San Diego for well over a year. In November 2012, after several days of deliberation, a jury convicted all three men of first-degree murder, along with robbery and shooting at an occupied vehicle. At sentencing the following January, the gunman, Abernathy, was ordered to serve 50 years to life; his two co-defendants received their own long prison terms. Three lives ended in prison; one ended on a road in Paradise Hills. No verdict rebalances that.
What gave the case its staying power is how routine the setup was. Garrett was not reckless. He did what a great many careful people do without a second thought — answered a normal-looking ad, brought someone with him, planned to meet and be home in twenty minutes. That is exactly why it resonated. If it could happen over a laptop listing on an ordinary Tuesday night, it could happen to almost anyone.
It cuts both ways — and it never really stopped
It would be easy to file this under "buyer beware" and move on, but sellers are drawn into the same trap from the opposite side. A listing for a device that doesn't exist can just as easily be used to lure a buyer to a chosen spot. In one federal case out of Washington, D.C., prosecutors described a robbery scheme built around a phantom MacBook Pro listing that ended in a killing, and the Justice Department later announced a prison sentence for one of the men involved. Whether you are the one holding the Mac or the one holding the cash, the risky ingredient is identical: a stranger and a private meeting.
And the pattern has never gone away; it has only moved platforms. Police departments and reporters now describe a steady stream of robberies — some of them fatal — tied to meetups arranged through Craigslist, OfferUp, and Facebook Marketplace. Covering one such death, NBC DFW noted how it renewed calls to use police "safe exchange zones" — monitored lots outside station houses that exist, in large part, because of cases like Garrett's.
If you do meet someone, meet them carefully
None of this means a private sale is impossible to do safely. It means the meetup is the part that has to be handled with real care. If you sell to a local buyer, meet in a busy, well-lit public place in daylight — ideally one of those police safe-exchange zones — bring someone with you, and, above everything the Berki case teaches, never pursue anyone or try to recover an item yourself if a deal goes wrong. The FTC's own summary of the safest private sale is to deal with a local buyer you can meet in person and only accept cash — sound advice, though as this case shows, no checklist makes a meeting with a stranger risk-free.
The surest way to avoid the danger is to not have the meeting at all. Selling a Mac to a dedicated buyer that ships and pays remotely takes the stranger, the parking lot, and the cash entirely out of the picture — which is the whole idea behind how Encore buys Macs. Mostly, though, we just hope Garrett Berki's story travels a little further. He went out one night to buy a computer, and the most important thing anyone can take from what happened to him is that trading a Mac should never cost anyone their safety.
Get an instant offer on your Mac
A real number in about 30 seconds — working or not. Free prepaid shipping, no seller fees, paid the day it arrives.*
Get my offerSources
- NBC 7 San Diego — Jurors Convict 3 in Craigslist Ad Murder
- KPBS — Three Convicted Of Murder In Craigslist Robbery-Killing
- FOX 5 San Diego — 3 guilty of killing student during Craigslist robbery
- FOX 5 San Diego — Teen gunman sentenced for Craigslist murder
- U.S. Department of Justice — District man sentenced for aiding and abetting murder in an online robbery scheme
- NBC DFW — Fatal Facebook Marketplace meetup highlights local safe exchange zones
- FTC Consumer Advice — Selling stuff online? Here's how to avoid a scam
More from Encore
Buying & SellingHow an Instant Mac Offer Actually Gets Priced
Model, configuration, condition, and live market comps: what goes into an instant Mac offer and why the number holds firm.
Sep 27, 2026 · 6 min read
Buying & SellingHow Prepaid Labels and Escrow Protect Both Sides of a Mac Sale
A tracked, insured prepaid label plus pay-after-inspection payment removes the two biggest risks of selling a Mac remotely. Here's how the mechanism works.
Sep 26, 2026 · 6 min read
Buying & SellingThe Real Risks of Selling Your Mac Locally for Cash
Fake payments, counterfeit bills, and unsafe meetups are the hidden costs of a local cash sale. Here's how to sell safely, or skip the risk entirely.
Sep 26, 2026 · 6 min read